Key Insights: The Value of Financial Advisors
- Financial Advisor Alpha: Vanguard’s 2022 quantified the value of financial advisors with research showing that advisors can boost total returns by up to 3%.
- Behavioral Coaching: The most significant value of financial advisors comes from coaching, preventing emotional decisions and adding up to 200 basis points to returns.
- Strategic Portfolio Rebalancing: Advisors can add around 14 basis points to overall returns through optimized rebalancing strategies.
- Tax-Efficiency and Asset Location: Advisors improve tax-efficiency through strategic asset location, contributing about 60 basis points to returns.
- Retirement Spending Strategies: Advisors guide tax-efficient withdrawal methods, adding an estimated 120 basis points to retirement returns.
Introduction
The question of whether hiring a financial advisor is worth the cost is a topic frequently debated both online and in real-world conversations. What is the value of financial advisors? While providing a quantitative answer to this question is challenging, Vanguard attempted to quantify the value of financial advisors in their white paper titled “Putting a Value on Your Value: Quantifying Vanguard Advisor’s Alpha.”
In financial parlance, “alpha” generally refers to the excess return an investment strategy yields over a given benchmark or index. However, the concept of alpha takes on a more multifaceted meaning when applied to financial advising. The alpha generated by a financial advisor is not solely about financial returns; it encompasses the total value that advisors add to help clients reach their financial goals. This view is not only supported by expert opinions and practical case studies but is now also substantiated by rigorous, credible research.
Vanguard’s 2022 Research
A groundbreaking paper by Vanguard in 2022 quantified the alpha that financial advisors can deliver. According to their study, the total return can be increased by up to 3% by using an advisor. This is broken down into several categories along with their potential addition:
- Cost-Effective Implementation: +30 basis points (bps)
- Rebalancing: +14 bps
- Behavioral Coaching: +200 bps
- Asset Location: +60 bps
- Spending Strategy (Withdraw Order): +120 bps
Note: One basis point is equivalent to 1/100th of a percentage point, or 0.01%
Vanguard did note that other areas like suitable asset allocation and total return investing vs. income investing also contribute to the alpha, but they were too difficult to quantify. Below is there entire table:
Cost-Effective Implementation
Financial advisors possess expertise in a wide range of investment options, enabling them to choose the most cost-effective investments for their clients. This expertise can translate into an estimated increase of 30 basis points (bps) in returns. However, the actual realized returns may vary depending on the client’s starting point. For example, if a client begins with a neglected portfolio or one that was initially set up in a 401(k) with suboptimal investment choices, the potential for increased value could be significantly greater. Conversely, if an investor is already well-informed, has researched lower-cost options, and implemented those findings, the increase in returns attributable to the advisor’s intervention may be smaller.
Rebalancing
Strategic rebalancing serves to optimize returns while mitigating risk. Financial advisors contribute discipline and expertise to execute this rebalancing efficiently, a strategy that Vanguard’s research suggests can add approximately 14 basis points (bps) to overall returns. However, the benefits of rebalancing can be complex to quantify. While it’s true that rebalancing may sometimes result in reduced returns, this typically occurs as a mechanism for realigning the portfolio with its original risk profile. Vanguard’s methodology factored in this increased risk when evaluating the added value of rebalancing.
It’s worth noting that the annual rebalancing strategy utilized in Vanguard’s study aligns with Purpose Built’s own rebalancing program. Additionally, Vanguard has published a white paper indicating that increasing the frequency of rebalancing does not necessarily improve returns. In fact, more frequent rebalancing can be counterproductive by incurring higher trading costs.
Behavioral Coaching
According to Vanguard, the most substantial source of alpha comes from behavioral coaching, contributing an impressive 200 basis points (bps) to returns. Financial advisors play a critical role in preventing clients from making rash decisions influenced by market volatility, thereby enhancing long-term gains. Unlike other factors discussed, such as cost-effective investment choices or rebalancing, which dedicated investors could potentially manage on their own with sufficient research, behavioral coaching is exceptionally challenging to replicate independently.
The value of behavioral coaching resembles the benefits one gains from consulting a mental health therapist for anxiety. Just as a therapist can help alleviate emotional stress, a trusted financial advisor can reduce financial anxiety and guide clients towards better financial decisions. This positive influence extends beyond merely optimizing a portfolio; it also translates into real-world advantages such as maximizing returns on employer benefits packages and making more financially sound choices when it comes to significant life purchases like homes and automobiles.
Asset Location
The strategic placement of investments in taxable versus tax-advantaged accounts can result in a notable increase in returns—specifically, around 60 basis points (bps), according to Vanguard’s research. Financial advisors offer invaluable expertise in tax planning, thereby adding another layer of value or “alpha” to a client’s investment strategy.
The principle behind this approach is to maximize the tax-efficiency of an overall investment portfolio. While each individual’s circumstances may differ, some general guidelines can be applied. For instance, taxable bonds, which generate interest income that is subject to regular income tax, are often better suited for tax-advantaged accounts like Traditional IRAs or 401(k)s. This allows the interest to grow tax-deferred until withdrawal, thus preserving more of the investment’s yield.
Similarly, assets with high growth potential may be optimally placed in Roth accounts, such as Roth IRAs or Roth 401(k)s. In these accounts, earnings grow tax-free, provided certain conditions are met. By allocating high-growth assets to Roth accounts, investors can maximize the benefit of the account’s tax-free growth feature, thereby optimizing the portfolio’s overall after-tax returns.
In summary, financial advisors leverage their tax-planning expertise to identify the most tax-efficient locations for various types of investments. This nuanced strategy not only increases potential returns but also contributes to the overall alpha generated for the client, making it a crucial component of comprehensive financial planning.
Spending Strategy (Drawdown)
Financial advisors offer significant value in guiding clients on the most tax-efficient methods for withdrawing funds during retirement, an approach that can add an estimated 120 basis points (bps) to total returns, according to Vanguard’s research. This involves utilizing a tax forecast to analyze both the client’s current tax situation and a projection of their future tax landscape. Vanguard includes a simple summary chart of the general plan:
The common assumption is that individuals will fall into a lower tax bracket upon retirement. However, this can vary widely depending on several factors, including the types of accounts used for savings. For example, moderate earners who have been diligent savers, primarily in tax-deferred accounts like Traditional IRAs or 401(k)s, may find themselves in a higher tax bracket when Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) commence.
Due to the complexities and variations in tax situations, an effective drawdown strategy needs to be formulated well in advance of actual retirement. This is where the expertise of a financial advisor can prove invaluable, enabling clients to navigate the maze of tax implications associated with retirement income sources. This leads us to the importance of thorough tax planning, a key component that enables the effective implementation of all these value-added strategies.
The Role of Tax Planning: Purpose Built’s Methodology
To effectively implement any of these alpha-generating strategies, thorough tax planning is indispensable. This is where Purpose Built’s methodology shines the brightest. Unlike traditional approaches that treat tax planning as an end-of-year activity, Purpose Built incorporates tax preparation and tax planning throughout the financial planning process.
By proactively considering tax implications at every stage, Purpose Built ensures that the implemented strategies are not only efficient from an investment perspective but are also optimized for tax benefits. This continuous, year-round focus on tax planning provides another layer of value that significantly contributes to the overall alpha generated for the client. It underscores the importance of an integrated approach to financial planning, one that considers every financial decision in the context of its tax implications.
Other Sources of Alpha
While Vanguard’s research was instrumental in quantifying the alpha generated in specific areas, financial advisors also offer other unquantifiable but significant forms of alpha:
- Comprehensive Financial Planning: Advisors take a 360-degree view of a client’s financial situation, offering advice on retirement planning, estate planning, and other specialized areas.
- Customized Service: Advisors provide personalized advice based on each client’s unique situation, which robo-advisors and financial products can’t replicate.
- Opportunity Cost & Time Savings: The time and energy saved by employing a financial advisor can be spent on other lucrative or fulfilling activities, adding another layer to the total alpha generated.
Conclusion
The alpha that financial advisors offer is multi-faceted and extends well beyond straightforward financial returns. It covers a comprehensive suite of financial planning services that are custom-tailored to meet each client’s unique needs. Research like Vanguard’s 2022 white paper provides tangible, quantifiable evidence of the value that a skilled financial advisor can bring to the table, thereby strengthening the compelling case for their services. Moreover, the inclusion of meticulous tax planning—particularly when executed through Purpose Built’s proven methodology—elevates this value to an even higher level, making the argument for engaging a financial advisor overwhelmingly strong.
If you’re ready to benefit from this multifaceted approach to financial planning and wealth management, don’t hesitate to reach out to Purpose Built. Our expertise in integrating tax planning throughout the financial planning process sets us apart and positions you for a more secure financial future. Contact us today to start realizing your financial goals.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Value of Financial Advisors?
The value of a financial advisor is multi-faceted and extends beyond just financial returns. According to Vanguard’s 2022 research, an advisor can increase your total returns by up to 3%.
What is Financial Advisor Alpha?
Financial Advisor Alpha refers to the additional value or returns that an advisor can generate for their clients. This includes behavioral coaching, tax-efficient strategies, and portfolio rebalancing, among other factors.
How Does Behavioral Coaching Affect My Returns?
Behavioral coaching is one of the most significant sources of “alpha,” potentially contributing up to 200 basis points to your returns. It helps prevent emotional decision-making during market volatility.
What is Asset Location and How Does it Affect Tax-Efficiency?
Asset location involves strategically placing your investments in taxable or tax-advantaged accounts to maximize tax efficiency. This can result in around a 60 basis point increase in returns.
How Can Rebalancing My Portfolio Benefit Me?
Strategic rebalancing can add approximately 14 basis points to your overall returns. More importantly, it serves to both optimize returns and mitigate risk.
What are Retirement Spending Strategies?
These are tax-efficient methods for withdrawing funds during retirement. Proper planning in this area can add an estimated 120 basis points to your total returns.
How Does Tax Planning Fit into Financial Advising?
Comprehensive tax planning is crucial for implementing any alpha-generating strategies effectively. It should be a continuous, year-round focus to optimize for tax benefits.
.jpg)
